Court News

Sh8,000 Police Towing Charge Declared Unconstitutional by High Court

Green utility vehicle on a road among other vehicles, with a gavel graphic representing a court ruling on police towing charges.
The High Court in Thika has declared an Sh8,000 police towing demand unconstitutional. PHOTO: Court Helicopter News

The High Court in Thika has declared a demand for Sh8,000 in towing charges by police officers unconstitutional, warning that motorists could be exposed to arbitrary charges and extortion in the absence of clear regulations.

In a judgment delivered on November 12, 2026, Justice L. N. Mugambi ruled that although police have powers under the Traffic Act to remove and detain vehicles in certain circumstances, those powers do not permit officers to impose unexplained towing charges on motorists.

The petition was filed by David Kimani Waithera, who challenged the detention of his vehicle, registration number KCK 799K, at Juja Police Station and the subsequent demand for Sh8,000 before its release.

ALSO READ

Court documents showed that Waithera was arrested at about 1:58am on December 25, 2025, in the Kwa Kairo area of Juja during a police traffic operation targeting motorists suspected of driving under the influence of alcohol.

Police told the court that Waithera appeared intoxicated and declined to undergo a breathalyser test. They argued that allowing him to continue driving or leaving the vehicle unattended would have been unsafe.

The officers consequently arranged for a private towing operator, identified as Harrison Nzuki, to transport the vehicle to Juja Police Station.

However, when Waithera returned to collect his vehicle, he was informed that he had to pay Sh8,000 in towing charges.

He challenged the demand, arguing that no invoice had been issued, the calculation of the amount had not been explained and the person entitled to receive the payment had not been identified.

He also questioned the engagement of the private towing operator, saying the police had not produced a contract, tender documents, prequalification records or a framework agreement authorising the arrangement.

The police maintained that the charges were based on standardised Automobile Association (AA) rates and that the vehicle had been removed under Sections 106 and 107 of the Traffic Act.

They further told the court that the vehicle had eventually been released after Waithera deposited Sh8,000 in court following an earlier court order.

However, Justice Mugambi found that the respondents had failed to provide documentary evidence supporting the amount demanded.

The judge noted that no invoice, demand note or explanation justifying the charges had been presented. The alleged towing service provider had also not sworn an affidavit explaining the amount, while the AA rates schedule relied upon by the police was not produced.

In a strong warning against arbitrary charges, the judge said motorists should not be left at the discretion of police officers and private towing operators to determine how much they must pay.

“Members of public cannot be left at the whim of the police and private service providers to impose towing charges under Section 106 and 107 as they please,” Justice Mugambi ruled.

The court further warned that allowing such an arrangement could amount to arbitrary seizure of property, describing it as akin to legalising extortion in the name of traffic enforcement.

The judge, however, acknowledged that requiring police to engage only prequalified towing companies may not always be practical, given that traffic incidents can occur anywhere and at any time.

He said officers could use the nearest available towing operator when necessary, but insisted that the charges must be guided by a clear and publicly ascertainable formula.

The court called for urgent law reform to address challenges arising from Sections 106 and 107 of the Traffic Act, particularly on how towing charges should be determined and imposed.

Although the judge declared the Sh8,000 demand unconstitutional, he declined to make a final determination on whether Waithera was liable to pay towing charges.

Instead, he directed that the question be determined by the traffic court handling his pending case, including whether the towing was justified and what amount, if any, was legally payable.

The judge ordered that the demand for Sh8,000 be suspended pending the conclusion of the traffic case.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE

Facebook WhatsApp Telegram X